The Buffalo Nickel Worth $601,000: A Hidden Treasure in Your Pocket

Published On: July 3, 2025
Buffalo Nickel Worth

Imagine finding a nickel worth $601,000 in your loose change! The Buffalo Nickel, a beloved U.S. coin, has some rare versions that can fetch massive sums due to unique errors or limited production. One such coin, the 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel, is valued at up to $601,000 and might still be hiding in circulation. This article explores the Buffalo Nickel’s history, why some are so valuable, and how you can hunt for these treasures. Let’s dive into the exciting world of coin collecting!

What Is the Buffalo Nickel?

The Buffalo Nickel, also called the Indian Head Nickel, is a five-cent coin minted by the U.S. from 1913 to 1938. Designed by James Earle Fraser, it features a Native American profile on the front (obverse) and a buffalo on the back (reverse). Its iconic design makes it a favorite among collectors, but certain rare versions stand out for their incredible value.

Why Is It Special?

The Buffalo Nickel’s unique design captures America’s history, with the Native American and buffalo symbolizing the nation’s past. However, what makes some of these coins worth a fortune are rare minting errors or low production numbers from specific years.

Why Is the Buffalo Nickel Worth $601,000?

Certain Buffalo Nickels are prized for their scarcity and unique flaws. The 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel, valued at $601,000, is a prime example due to a rare minting error where the date “1918” was stamped over “1917.” This mistake, combined with the coin’s condition, drives its value. Here’s why some Buffalo Nickels are so valuable:

Key Factors That Increase Value

  • Minting Errors: Errors like the 1918/7-D overdate, where two dates are visible, are extremely rare.
  • Rarity: Some years or mint marks (like “D” for Denver) had low production, making them hard to find.
  • Condition: Coins in great shape, with clear details and minimal wear, fetch higher prices.
  • Historical Appeal: The Buffalo Nickel’s design and era make it a collector’s favorite.

The 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel

The 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel is one of the rarest coins in U.S. history. During production, a 1918 date was mistakenly stamped over a 1917 die, creating a visible error. Only a few of these coins exist, and one in excellent condition can be worth up to $601,000 at auction.

Rare Buffalo Nickels to Look For

Not all Buffalo Nickels are worth $601,000, but several are valuable. Here’s a table of key dates and varieties to watch for:

YearMint MarkDescriptionEstimated Value
1918/7-DDOverdate error$10,000–$601,000
1937-DDThree-Legged Buffalo$500–$100,000
1916NoneDoubled Die Obverse$1,000–$50,000
1926-SSLow mintage$100–$5,000+
1935NoneDoubled Die Reverse$50–$1,000+

Note: Values depend on the coin’s condition and market demand.

How to Find a Valuable Buffalo Nickel

You don’t need to be a coin expert to start searching for valuable Buffalo Nickels. They might still be in circulation, hiding in old coin jars or collections. Here’s how to begin your treasure hunt:

Where to Look

  • Pocket Change: Check your spare change for old nickels.
  • Coin Rolls: Buy rolls of nickels from banks and search through them.
  • Flea Markets and Estate Sales: Old coin collections often surface at these places.
  • Coin Shows: Attend local or online events to find rare nickels.

What to Check

  • Date and Mint Mark: Look for key dates like 1918/7-D or mint marks (D, S, or none) below the buffalo.
  • Errors: Use a magnifying glass to spot errors like overdates or a three-legged buffalo.
  • Condition: Check for wear. Coins with sharp details are more valuable.

Tools You’ll Need

  • A magnifying glass or loupe
  • A coin reference guide (like the “Red Book”)
  • A soft cloth to handle coins (avoid touching them to prevent damage)

Tips for Selling a Valuable Nickel

If you find a rare Buffalo Nickel, here’s how to get the best price:

  1. Get It Graded: Services like PCGS or NGC can certify your coin’s authenticity and condition, increasing its value.
  2. Research Prices: Check recent auction sales for similar coins to set a fair price.
  3. Sell Through Trusted Channels: Use reputable auction houses, coin dealers, or platforms like eBay.
  4. Store Safely: Keep your coin in a protective holder to maintain its condition.

Why Collectors Love Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickels are more than just money—they’re pieces of American history. The Native American and buffalo imagery connects to the early 20th century, making them nostalgic. The thrill of finding a rare coin, especially one worth $601,000, adds excitement to collecting. Whether you’re new to coins or a seasoned collector, the Buffalo Nickel’s charm is hard to resist.

Conclusion

The Buffalo Nickel worth $601,000 is a hidden gem that could be in your pocket or an old coin jar. By learning about key dates, minting errors, and where to look, you can join the hunt for these valuable coins. Check your change, visit flea markets, or dive into coin collecting to uncover a treasure. Who knows? The next $601,000 nickel could be yours!

FAQs

Why is the 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel so valuable?

The 1918/7-D is rare because of a minting error where the 1918 date was stamped over 1917, making it one of the rarest Buffalo Nickels.

Can I still find valuable Buffalo Nickels in circulation?

Yes, though rare, some Buffalo Nickels may still be in old collections, coin jars, or loose change.

How do I know if my Buffalo Nickel is

Leave a Comment